Friday, December 13, 2019

Q3 2019 Z.1 Flow of Funds: Repo Madness

Q3 was yet another fascinating quarter for U.S. finance. Total Credit (Non-Financial, Financial and Foreign U.S. borrowings) jumped a nominal $1.075 TN, the strongest quarterly gain since Q4 2007’s $1.159 TN, ending September at $74.862 TN (348% of GDP). Total Credit was up $3.230 TN over the past four quarter (4.5%) and $6.446 TN (9.4%) in two years.

Non-Financial Debt (NFD) surged $835 billion during the quarter – double Q2’s growth and the strongest expansion since Q1 2004’s (aberrational) $1.234 TN. At $53.896 TN, NFD ended September at a record 250% of GDP, up from previous cycle peaks of 226% at year-end ‘07 and 183% to end 1999. On a percentage basis, NFD expanded at a 6.32% rate, up from Q2’s 3.15% and Q3 2018’s 4.13%.

Our federal government continues to command the debt bullet train, expanding borrowings at a 10.4% pace during the quarter (strongest since Q1 ’18). Treasury Securities surged a notable $757 billion during the quarter to a record $18.572 TN. Treasury Securities jumped $1.154 TN over the past year and $2.341 TN in two years. Treasury Securities-to-GDP increased to 86%, up from Q4 07’s 41%. A broader measure of Treasury Liabilities ended Q3 at $21.048 TN, or 98% of GDP.

Bank (“Private Depository Institutions”) Assets expanded $245 billion during the quarter, or 5.0% annualized, to $19.753 TN. One-year growth was $829 billion, or 4.4%. Loans increased $118 billion (to $11.580 TN), or 4.1% annualized. Bank Mortgage Loans increased $57 billion, or 4.1% annualized, to $5.597 TN (Total U.S. Mortgage Lending increased $185 billion, the strongest quarterly gain since Q4 ’07).

While the bank lending business was rather humdrum, the capital markets side of things was anything but. Bank Debt Securities holdings were up $141 billion, or 12.5% annualized, during Q3 to a record $4.639 TN. Treasuries gained $84 billion ($205bn y-o-y) and Agency/MBS $54 billion ($265bn y-o-y). Total Debt Securities holdings jumped $464 billion, or 11.1%, over four quarters. Bank “repo” Assets declined $23 billion during the quarter to $736 billion, though one-year growth of $193 billion was up 36%.

And while on the subject of booming capital markets, Broker/Dealer Assets jumped $102 billion, or 12% annualized, during Q3 to $3.588 TN (high since Q1 ’13). Over the past year, Broker/Dealer assets surged $394 billion, the strongest one-year growth since 2007. For the quarter, Debt Securities holdings were unchanged at $450 billion, with Treasuries declining $21 billion to $213 billion. Loans increased $3.0 billion, while Equities and Misc. Assets each fell about $5.0 billion. What, then, was the source of such robust overall growth? Security Repurchase Agreements rose $103.3 billion, or 30% annualized. Over four quarters, “repo” Assets surged $302 billion, accounting for 77% of Broker/Dealer Asset growth over the period.

Let’s take a brief diversion from Z.1 data. M2 “money” supply surged an unprecedented $1.044 TN over the past year, or 7.3%. Institutional Money Fund Assets (not included in M2) jumped another $390 billion, or 20.8%. Year-to-date, the S&P500 has returned 28.9%. The Nasdaq Composite is up 31.6%. The Semiconductors (SOX) have surged 55.5%, with the Nasdaq Computer Index up 45.8%. The Banks (BKX) have gained 31.3%. Treasury bonds (TLT) have returned 16.9%. Investment-grade corporates (LQD) enjoy a 2019 return of 17.5%, with junk bonds (HYG) returning 13.3%. Gold has gained 15% so far this year, with Silver up almost 10%. Real estate prices have continued to inflate, along with private businesses, art, professional sports franchises, collectible, etc. It has indeed been the spectacular “everything rally.”

Such extraordinary asset inflation is possible only with some underlying Monetary Disorder. I have argued that international securities finance is at the epicenter of historic Global Monetary Disorder and resulting runaway asset inflation and Bubbles.

When a new Fed Z.1 report was available during the mortgage finance Bubble period, I would immediately jump to the Fed’s “Total Mortgages,” “Agency- and GSE-Backed Securities,” and “Asset Backed Securities” pages. I would then move on to “Fed Funds and Security Repurchase Agreements” (i.e. “repo”). These days, I go directly to “repo” data for illumination of this period’s key source of Monetary Disorder. Q3 did not disappoint.

Total “repo” (“Federal Funds and Security Repurchase Agreements”) Liabilities jumped another $222 billion during the quarter to $4.502 TN, the high going back to Q3 2008. Over the past year, “repo” surged a record $932 billion, or 26.1%. For perspective, “repo” Liabilities rose on average $51.9 billion annually over the past five years (2014-2018). And the $932 billion gain during the past four quarters is more than double the biggest annual rise over the past decade (2010’s $422bn gain that followed the $1.672 TN two-year crisis-period contraction). Ominously, the past year’s gain also surpasses the previous record four-quarter gain ($824bn) for the period ended in June 2007. “Repo” Assets (as opposed to Liabilities) surged $1.087 TN over the past four quarters to a record $4.813 TN.

Who holds these Trillions of “repos”? Broker/Dealers lead with $1.467 TN, followed by Money Market Funds at $1.173 TN; Rest of World at $781 billion; Foreign Banking Offices in U.S. at $403 billion; and the Fed’s recently acquired $203 billion. In extraordinary growth, over the past year “repo” holdings have increased $302 billion for the Broker/Dealers; $252 billion within Money Market Funds; $145 billion for Rest of World; $98 billion at Foreign Banks in the U.S.; and $203 billion held by the Fed.

Total Debt Securities (TDS) gained $1.020 TN during the quarter, or 8.9% annualized, to a record $46.742 TN. This huge quarterly expansion was second only to Q1 2004’s $1.177 TN. For comparison, TDS increased $270 billion during Q2 and $449 billion in Q3 ’18. TDS increased $2.115 TN over the past year. For perspective, this is 50% above the average annual growth over the past decade and the largest expansion since 2007. TDS ended September at 217% of GDP (slightly below Q1 ‘13’s record 223%).

Total Equities were down somewhat ($222bn) for the quarter to $49.560 TN, or 230% of GDP. And while this was below Q3 2018’s record 243% of GDP, booming Q4 equities markets will push this ratio back toward all-time highs. Total (Debt and Equities) Securities ended Q3 at a record $96.302 TN, or 447% of GDP (below Q3 2018’s record 458%). For perspective, Total Securities posted previous cycle peaks of 379% of GDP during Q3 2007 and 359% to end Q1 2000.

Subdued equities put somewhat of a damper on the Bubble in perceived household wealth. Household (and Non-Profits) Assets increased $749 billion during Q3 to a record $130.218 TN. And with Household Liabilities up $176 billion to $16.386 TN, Household Net Worth increased $573 billion during the quarter to a record $113.832 TN. For perspective, Household Net Worth peaked during Q3 2007 at $71.346 TN. Household Net Worth has almost doubled from the $60.221 TN trough back in Q1 2009. Surely helping explain the resilient U.S. consumer, Household Net Worth jumped $3.726 TN over the past year and $10.854 TN in two years. Household Net Worth-to-GDP ended September at 528% (down slightly from Q4 17’s record 532%). Previous cycle peaks were at 492% of GDP during Q1 2007 and 446% at Q1 2000.

U.S. securities/“repo” finance is clearly a major source of liquidity for the markets as well as the real economy. Yet this Bubble Dynamic is undoubtedly global, with international securities finance instrumental to inflating securities and asset markets around the world. A Bloomberg article this week referenced a $9.0 TN European “repo” market. There are also large repo markets in Japan and throughout Asia. How much finance used to leverage global securities is originating out of the likes of Hong Kong, Singapore and Shanghai - not to mention the Cayman Islands and Luxembourg? How much global “repo” finance has been flowing into U.S. debt markets?

Rest of World (ROW) holdings of U.S. Assets increased $397 billion during Q3, down sharply from blistering Q2’s $1.017 TN and Q1’s $2.250 TN. After the remarkable Q4 decline ($2.125 TN), ROW holdings are up an astonishing $3.664 TN in nine months, surely a significant contributor to booming asset prices and general Monetary Disorder. In three quarters, ROW holdings of U.S. Debt Securities surged $959 billion, or 11.4%, to a record $12.137 TN. Treasuries jumped $510 billion (to $6.775 TN); Corp Bonds $346 billion (to $3.956 TN); and Agency Securities $93 billion (to $1.171 TN).

Notably, ROW U.S. “repo” Liabilities jumped $292 billion, or 43%, in nine months to $1.207 TN. How much of this ROW market activity – securities buying and “repo” finance – emanates from global “repo” and off-shore financial centers funding leveraged speculation in U.S. securities?

Markets now relish “clarity.” A “phase 1” U.S./China trade deal has, at long last, been inked. The Tories big election win ensures a decisive Brexit. Meanwhile, the (King of Asymmetric) Fed has essentially signaled no rate hikes until after next year’s election (more likely the 2021 inauguration). Any inkling of instability would certainly elicit additional monetary stimulus. Perhaps bond markets are beginning to have an issue with all of this. Is the Fed really going to expand its balance sheet $500 billion to quell any potential year-end “repo” market pressure? Today’s backdrop becomes even more reminiscent of fateful 1999 (and Y2K).


For the Week:

The S&P500 gained 0.7% (up 26.4% y-t-d), and the Dow added 0.4% (up 20.6%). The Utilities were little changed (up 19.3%). The Banks jumped another 1.5% (up 31.3%), and the Broker/Dealers rose 0.6% (up 22.4%). The Transports rallied 0.6% (up 17.5%). The S&P 400 Midcaps were about unchanged (up 21.7%), while the small cap Russell 2000 added 0.3% (up 21.5%). The Nasdaq100 advanced 1.1% (up 34.1%). The Semiconductors surged 4.2% (up 55.5%). The Biotechs increased 0.3% (up 20.6%). With bullion rising $16, the HUI gold index jumped 3.9% (up 40.6%).

Three-month Treasury bill rates ended the week at 1.525%. Two-year government yields slipped a basis point to 1.61% (down 88bps y-t-d). Five-year T-note yields declined one basis point to 1.65% (down 86bps). Ten-year Treasury yields fell two bps to 1.82% (down 86bps). Long bond yields declined two bps to 2.25% (down 76bps). Benchmark Fannie Mae MBS yields dropped four bps to 2.69% (down 80bps).

Greek 10-year yields sank 15 bps to 1.34% (down 306bps y-t-d). Ten-year Portuguese yields dropped five bps 0.37% (down 135bps). Italian 10-year yields sank nine bps to 1.26% (down 148bps). Spain's 10-year yields fell eight bps to 0.41% (down 100bps). German bund yields were unchanged at negative 0.29% (down 53bps). French yields declined three bps to 0.01% (down 70bps). The French to German 10-year bond spread narrowed three to 30 bps. U.K. 10-year gilt yields gained two bps to 0.79% (down 49bps). U.K.'s FTSE equities index jumped 1.6% (up 9.3% y-t-d).

Japan's Nikkei Equities Index surged 2.9% (up 20.0% y-t-d). Japanese 10-year "JGB" yields slipped a basis point to negative 0.02% (down 2bps y-t-d). France's CAC40 gained 0.8% (up 25.1%). The German DAX equities index rose 0.9% (up 25.8%). Spain's IBEX 35 equities index jumped 1.9% (up 12.0%). Italy's FTSE MIB index added 0.6% (up 27.3%). EM equities surged higher. Brazil's Bovespa index gained 1.3% (up 23.7%), and Mexico's Bolsa surged 5.5% (up 6.3%). South Korea's Kospi index jumped 4.2% (up 6.3%). India's Sensex equities index gained 1.4% (up 13.7%). China's Shanghai Exchange rose 1.9% (up 19.0%). Turkey's Borsa Istanbul National 100 index added 1.5% (up 21.0%). Russia's MICEX equities index jumped 2.3% (up 26.5%).

Investment-grade bond funds saw inflows of $4.609 billion, and junk bond funds posted inflows of $939 million (from Lipper).

Freddie Mac 30-year fixed mortgage rates rose five bps 3.73% (down 90bps y-o-y). Fifteen-year rates gained five bps to 3.19% (down 88bps). Five-year hybrid ARM rates slipped three bps to 3.36% (down 68bps). Bankrate's survey of jumbo mortgage borrowing costs had 30-year fixed rates up six bps to 3.98% (down 55bps).

Federal Reserve Credit last week surged $27.9bn to $4.047 TN, with a 13-week gain of $321 billion. Over the past year, Fed Credit contracted $1.4bn. Fed Credit inflated $1.236 Trillion, or 44%, over the past 370 weeks. Elsewhere, Fed holdings for foreign owners of Treasury, Agency Debt dropped $11.7 billion last week to $3.405 TN. "Custody holdings" gained $20.7 billion, or 0.6% y-o-y.

M2 (narrow) "money" supply was little changed last week at $15.365 TN. "Narrow money" surged $1.044 TN, or 7.3%, over the past year. For the week, Currency increased $5.1bn. Total Checkable Deposits declined $7.4bn, while Savings Deposits added $1.9bn. Small Time Deposits slipped $1.4bn. Retail Money Funds gained $1.5bn.

Total money market fund assets jumped $40.1bn to $3.619 TN. Money Funds gained $616bn y-o-y, or 20.5%.

Total Commercial Paper increased $3.9bn to $1.139 TN. CP was up $49.3bn, or 4.5% year-over-year.

Currency Watch:

December 6 – Reuters (Huizhong Wu and Dominique Patton): “China’s foreign exchange reserves fell $9 billion in November to $3.096 trillion…, as Washington and Beijing remained locked in negotiations over an interim trade agreement.”

The U.S. dollar index declined 0.5% to 97.172 (up 1.0% y-t-d). For the week on the upside, the South Korean won increased 1.6%, the British pound 1.5%, the Mexican peso 1.4%, the Norwegian krone 1.1%, the Swedish krona 1.1%, the Brazilian real 0.8%, the Swiss franc 0.7%, the Canadian dollar 0.7%, the South African rand 0.6%, the euro 0.6%, the Singapore dollar 0.5%, the Australian dollar 0.5% and New Zealand dollar 0.5%. On the downside, the Japanese yen declined 0.7%. The Chinese renminbi gained 0.84% versus the dollar this week (down 1.4% y-t-d).

Commodities Watch:

The Bloomberg Commodities Index gained 1.5% this week (up 3.2% y-t-d). Spot Gold rose 1.1% to $1,476 (up 15.1%). Silver rallied 2.5% to $17.012 (up 9.5%). WTI crude rose 87 cents to $60.07 (up 32%). Gasoline gained 1.0% (up 26%), while Natural Gas dropped 1.6% (down 22%). Copper jumped 2.1% (up 6%). Wheat recovered 1.5% (up 6%). Corn gained 1.1% (up 2%).

Market Instability Watch:

December 8 – Bloomberg (Liz McCormick): “The September mayhem in the U.S. repo market suggests there’s a structural problem in this vital corner of finance and the incident wasn’t just a temporary hiccup, according to… the Bank for International Settlements. This market, which relies heavily on just four big U.S. banks for funding, was upended in part because those firms now hold more of their liquid assets in Treasuries relative to what they park at the Federal Reserve, officials… concluded… That meant ‘their ability to supply funding at short notice in repo markets was diminished.’ And hedge funds are financing more investments through repo, which ‘appears to have compounded the strains,’ the researchers added.”

December 12 – Wall Street Journal (Michael S. Derby): “The Federal Reserve Bank of New York said… it is again increasing the scope of liquidity operations it is willing to offer financial markets to ensure money-market rates remain relatively calm over an uncertain year-end. The bank, which handles the implementation of monetary policy goals laid out by the rate-setting Federal Open Market Committee, said its provisions of liquidity available via overnight repurchase agreements will rise to $150 billion, from the current $120 billion cap, in operations planned for between Dec. 31 and Jan. 2.”

December 12 – Bloomberg (Alex Harris and Matthew Boesler): “The Federal Reserve Bank of New York is getting its house in order, ramping up measures to combat end-of-year funding risks and tapping permanent leaders to steer its interactions with markets. The branch… said it would conduct additional repurchase-agreement operations that could take the amount its support for funding markets over the crucial year-end period to more than half a trillion dollars… An announcement by the Fed Thursday means that the central bank is now planning to offer a total of $490 billion in liquidity via repo operations for the turn of the year, including the $75 billion that it has already pumped in through three earlier term actions. It announced new term operations totaling $365 billion that will take place this month and next, as well as various changes to its overnight actions.”

December 11 – Reuters (Saqib Iqbal Ahmed and April Joyner): “The options-based Black Swan index may be signaling surging demand from investors for protection against a stock market crash, but Wall Street analysts see little reason to panic. The Cboe Skew Index is near a 14-month high. It tracks the implied volatility of deep out-of-the-money options - that is, contracts that need a large move in the market before they come into play - on the S&P 500. On Monday, the Skew Index hit 136.56, its highest since October 2018.”

December 8 – Bloomberg (Anooja Debnath and Charlotte Ryan): “Currency traders may face new dangers when volatility returns to the market, after a spell of innovation in the industry coincided with a period of unusual calm. An abundance of trading venues means that investors and dealers are spreading their capital more thinly than before, fragmenting liquidity across multiple platforms. That raises the risk of liquidity drying up at some venues during periods of market turmoil, the Bank for International Settlements warns.”

December 8 – Wall Street Journal (Michael Wursthorn): “The S&P 500 is having its best run in six years, but individual investors are fleeing stock funds at the fastest pace in decades… Investors have pulled $135.5 billion from U.S. stock-focused mutual funds and exchange-traded funds so far this year, the biggest withdrawals on record, according to… Refinitiv Lipper, which tracked the data going back to 1992.”

Trump Administration Watch:

December 13 – Bloomberg (Shawn Donnan, Miao Han, and Jenny Leonard): “The U.S. and China said they agreed to the details of the first phase of a broader trade agreement in a move that will see the U.S. reduce tariffs, at least temporarily calm fears of an escalating trade war between the world’s two largest economies. The deal announced hinges on China increasing purchases of American farm goods such as soybeans and pork, and making new commitments on intellectual property, forced technology transfer and currency. …President Donald Trump said he expects China’s agriculture buying to hit $50 billion annually ‘pretty soon.’ The U.S. will also suspend new import taxes that were set to take effect on Sunday covering $160 billion of products such as smartphones and toys, U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer told reporters… The Asian nation committed to increase imports of U.S. goods and services by no less than $200 billion more than the 2017 level over the next two years, he said.”

December 12 – Reuters (Howard Schneider): “After three interest rate cuts and a fresh round of record highs for U.S. stock markets, has President Donald Trump lost interest in the Federal Reserve? A count of tweets from Trump about U.S. monetary policy suggest a detente may have taken hold between an elected leader who has lambasted Fed officials with insults like ‘clueless’ and ‘boneheads’ and a central bank whose rate cuts have helped buffer the economy from the administration’s own unpredictable trade and tariff policies. On Wednesday, the Fed left interest rates unchanged at the end of a two-day policy meeting, and signaled it was likely to keep them at the current level until at least 2021 - after the Nov. 3 presidential election in which Trump hopes to win a second term.”

Federal Reserve Watch:

December 11 – Wall Street Journal (Nick Timiraos): “The Federal Reserve held interest rates steady and signaled no appetite to raise them soon. After lowering rates at their three previous meetings to guard the U.S. economy from the effects of trade tensions and a global slowdown, Fed officials… indicated comfort with leaving monetary policy on hold through next year while keeping an eye on those risks. ‘Our economic outlook remains a favorable one,’ said Fed Chairman Jerome Powell. The rate-setting committee voted 10-0 to leave the central bank’s benchmark rate in a range between 1.5% and 1.75%... New projections released after the meeting showed most officials think rates are low enough to stimulate growth.”

December 11 – Reuters (Jonnelle Marte): “With memories of September’s historic spike in short-term funding costs still raw, Wall Street and the Federal Reserve are gearing up for another potential cash crunch at year end. Liquidity levels will be tested as early as Monday, when Wall Street firms have to shell over cash to the U.S. Treasury for this week’s government bond sales and businesses draw down reserves to make quarterly tax payments - events that could drain more than $100 billion in liquidity from the banking system… And a new wild card may come into play this month. Some large banks may scale back lending in the repo market in an effort to shrink their balance sheets to avoid regulatory penalties…”

December 11 – Bloomberg (Alex Harris, Benjamin Purvis, and Christopher Condon): “The Federal Reserve is willing to extend its reserve management related purchases of Treasuries to coupon-bearing securities if needed, according to Chairman Jerome Powell. ‘We’re not at this place, but if it does become appropriate for us to purchase other short-term coupon securities, then we would be prepared to do that if the need arises,’ he said at his post-decision news conference... The Fed is ‘willing to adapt’ its strategy on bill purchases, Powell said.”

December 9 – Financial Times (Joe Rennison): “Investors snapped up a further $25bn in short-term loans from the Federal Reserve on Monday, seeking to shore up financing over the end of the year. It marks the third ‘repo’ operation in which the New York branch of the US central bank has offered the loans in exchange for Treasuries and other high quality collateral… Demand was in line with last week’s operation at $43bn for the $25bn on offer. The continued demand for cash despite the Fed’s operations has unnerved some investors…”

December 11 – Reuters (Jonnelle Marte): “The Federal Reserve’s efforts to calm money markets could fall short at the end of the year, potentially leading to a spike in Treasury yields and forcing the central bank to resort to launch a round of quantitative easing, a Credit Suisse analyst warned this week.”

U.S. Bubble Watch:

December 11 – Associated Press (Paul Wiseman): “The U.S. budget deficit rose by 2% last month to $209 billion, another step in a journey back toward $1 trillion-a-year budget shortfalls. The… federal government took in $225 billion in tax and other revenue but spent a record $434 billion in November… The Congressional Budget Office is forecasting that the deficit for 2020 will hit $1 trillion and will stay above $1 trillion for the next decade. The country last ran annual $1 trillion annual deficits from 2009 through 2012 during and after the financial crisis… So far this budget year, the government is running a deficit of $343 billion, up 12% from a year earlier.”

December 11 – Reuters (Lucia Mutikani): “U.S. consumer prices increased solidly in November, which together with labor market strength could support the Federal Reserve’s intention to keep interest rates steady indefinitely after reducing borrowing costs three times this year… The consumer price index rose 0.3% last month as households paid more for gasoline and electricity, and food prices increased for a third consecutive month. The CPI advanced 0.4% in October. In the 12 months through November, the CPI shot up 2.1% after gaining 1.8% in October.”

December 11 – Reuters (Lucia Mutikani): “U.S. worker productivity fell by the most in nearly four years in the third quarter…, while growth in unit labor costs was not as robust as initially thought. …Nonfarm productivity, which measures hourly output per worker, decreased at a 0.2% annualized rate in the last quarter, the biggest drop since the fourth quarter of 2015.”

December 13 – Reuters (Lucia Mutikani): “U.S. retail sales increased less than expected in November as Americans cut back on discretionary spending, which could see economists dialing back economic growth forecasts for the fourth quarter. …Retail sales rose 0.2% last month. Data for October was revised up to show retail sales increasing 0.4% instead of gaining 0.3%... Economists… forecast retail sales would accelerate 0.5% in November. Compared to November last year, retail sales increased 3.3%.”

December 10 – Bloomberg (Jeff Kearns): “Sentiment among small U.S. businesses climbed by the most in more than a year as more owners said profit trends are looking up and that it’s a favorable time for expansion, adding to signs that a key part of the economy is holding up in the fourth quarter. The National Federation of Independent Business optimism index rose 2.3 points in November to a four-month high of 104.7, topping all estimates…”

December 10 – Wall Street Journal (Ben Eisen): “Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are pulling back on some mortgages meant to make homeownership more affordable, their latest effort to rein in risk at the behest of their regulator. The two companies are cutting back on the proportion of loans they back to borrowers with small down payments, for example, and mortgages to deeply indebted borrowers. The regulator, the Federal Housing Finance Agency, says it wants Fannie and Freddie to be prepared for a possible economic downturn.”

December 12 – New York Times (Alexandra Stevenson): “A decade ago, natural gas was heralded as the fuel of the future. In shale fields across the country, hydraulic fracturing uncorked a lucrative new source of supply. Energy giants like Exxon Mobil and Chevron snapped up smaller companies to get in on the action, and investors poured billions of dollars into export terminals to ship gas to China and Europe. The boom has given way to a bust. A glut of cheap natural gas is wreaking havoc on the energy industry, and companies are shutting down drilling rigs, filing for bankruptcy protection and slashing the value of shale fields they had acquired in recent years.”

December 12 – Bloomberg (Jennifer Surane and Shahien Nasiripour): “Americans are projected to fall seriously behind on their credit card bills at the highest rate in a decade as banks push a record number of people to get plastic. The share of credit card borrowers who are at least 90 days past due on their accounts will probably tick up to 2.01% next year, the highest level since 2010, according to… TransUnion.”

December 9 – Reuters (Joshua Franklin and Anirban Sen): “More and more companies are putting plans for U.S. initial public offerings (IPO) on ice this year because of investor pushback against their valuations, creating a backlog that could make stock market debuts more challenging in 2020. While 2019 had promised to be a bumper year for IPOs, investor sentiment quickly soured… This has led to companies’ postponing listing plans. Some 44 companies withdrew their IPO registration in 2019 as of Dec. 3, up almost 50% on 2018 and the highest level since 2016…”

December 11 – CNBC (Maggie Fitzgerald): “2019 is the year of CEO departures. In November, 148 chief executives left their posts, according to business and executive coaching firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas. Only five more CEOs need to depart for 2019 to be the highest year on record, and we already know of a few CEOs out in December.”

China Watch:

December 12 – Reuters (Cate Cadell): “Senior Chinese diplomat Wang Yi said on Friday that the United States had seriously damaged the hard-won mutual trust between the countries by criticizing Beijing over issues such as Hong Kong and the treatment of Muslim Uighurs. ‘Such behavior is almost paranoid, and is indeed rare in international exchanges, seriously damaging the hard-won foundation of mutual trust between China and the United States, and seriously weakening the United States’ international credibility,’ said State Councillor Wang.”

December 7 – Reuters (Dominique Patton): “China’s top diplomat Yang Jiechi told U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo… that the United States should stop interfering in China’s internal affairs, according to… state TV. Citing the passing of the Uighur Human Rights Policy Act of 2019 and the Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act of 2019, Yang said the United States had seriously violated international relations, and urged Washington to ‘correct its mistakes’ and ‘immediately stop interfering in China’s internal affairs’.”

December 8 – Bloomberg: “The Chinese government is taking further steps to remove foreign technology from state agencies and other organizations, a clear sign of determination for more independence amid escalating tensions with the U.S. Beijing will likely replace as many as 20 million computers at government agencies with domestic products over the next three years, according to research from China Securities. More than 100 trial projects for domestic products were completed in July… The Financial Times newspaper said the Communist Party’s Central Office earlier this year ordered state offices and public institutions to shift away from foreign hardware and software.”

December 12 – New York Times (Alexandra Stevenson): “China’s companies racked up some towering bills as they expanded, and the world’s investors and lenders rushed to offer them even more money. Now the bills are coming due, and a growing number of Chinese companies can’t pay up, in a sign that the world’s No. 2 economy is feeling the stress from its worst slowdown in nearly three decades. Two high-profile companies — a giant government-run trading firm and a conglomerate backed by China’s most distinguished university — are the latest to join a long list of Chinese businesses that have run short of cash when it was time to pay back their debts. Chinese corporate borrowers have defaulted on nearly $20 billion in loans this year. The amount is small compared with China’s overall economy, but the toll is rising. Chinese companies owe hundreds of billions of dollars in debt that is coming due over the next two years, including more than $200 billion owed to lenders and investors around the globe.”

December 11 – Bloomberg: “A major Chinese commodities trader became the biggest dollar bond defaulter among the nation’s state-owned companies in two decades, in a moment of reckoning for Beijing as it struggles to contain credit risk in a weakening economy. Tewoo Group Corp. announced results of its unprecedented debt restructuring, which saw a majority of its investors accepting heavy losses. This is expected to reshape investors’ perceptions about government-owned borrowers whose identity has for years offered a relatively strong sense of security.”

December 8 – Bloomberg: “The latest bond failure by a Chinese local government investment arm has rekindled concerns about a group of borrowers whose outlook is closely tied to Beijing’s shifting definition of its implicit backing. The debt woes faced by Hohhot Economic & Technological Development Zone Investment Development Group, a local government financing vehicle from Inner Mongolia, have sent chills among investors holding other such LGFV bonds, driving prices sharply lower for some.”

December 10 – Bloomberg (Denise Wee): “Closer linkages between China’s onshore and offshore bond markets are threatening to spread contagion from local defaults. As the nation’s economy slows and liquidity tightens, its weakest companies are facing repayment woes. This, in turn, is creating jitters offshore. Growing participation by Chinese investors in the dollar bond market has led to concentration risk, with such buyers now dumping their holdings at the first hint of trouble. Asian junk notes -- the majority of which are from Chinese issuers -- suffered their worst losses last week since August, as a string of onshore nonpayments doused cold water on a rally.”

December 9 – Reuters (Lusha Zhang and Huizhong Wu): “China’s consumer inflation climbed to nearly eight-year peaks in November as pork prices doubled, but factory-gate prices remained in the red, adding to uncertainty over whether the manufacturing sector is bottoming out as trade risks persist… Consumer prices in November rose 4.5% on year, the fastest pace seen since January 2012… That topped analysts’ expectations of 4.2% and October’s 3.8% rise.”

December 10 – Financial Times (Sun Yu): “A surge in China’s consumer inflation to a seven-year high coupled with a decline in the producer price index are squeezing Beijing’s options to ease monetary policy. The official consumer price index rose to 4.5% in November…, while the PPI fell 1.4%, its fifth consecutive month of decline. Analysts said soaring consumer inflation, powered by runaway pork prices, and falling raw material prices that pointed to weak industrial demand, were limiting China’s policy tools to fight the economic downturn.”

December 11 – Bloomberg: “Vehicle sales in China are set to fall about 8% this year, an industry body said, the second straight annual drop for the world’s biggest auto market as consumers stay away from showrooms amid a cooling economy… The drop compares with about a 3% decline in 2018, when sales fell for the first time since 1990.”

December 11 – Financial Times (Don Weinland): “A flurry of Chinese banks are being forced to buy back shares to stabilise their stock prices following a series of bank bailouts and mounting pressure on the country’s financial system. At least 10 small, listed banks have been required by local regulations to purchase their own shares after their stock traded below net asset value per share for more than 20 consecutive days. The share purchases, called ‘stock price stabilisation plans’, are mandatory for companies whose stocks perform poorly within the first three years after listing, and are common among China’s listed companies.”

December 11 – Reuters (Felix Tam and Donny Kwok): “Thousands of Hong Kong protesters gathered… to mark six months since their first major clash with police, when they blocked legislators from advancing an extradition bill that has since been scrapped. On June 12, police fired tear gas and rubber bullets to disperse protesters occupying roads near the legislative council just as it was to give a second reading to the bill that would have allowed criminal suspects to be extradited to mainland China, where courts are controlled by the Communist Party.”

December 7 – Associated Press (Kate O'Donnell-Lamb and Jessie Pang): “Vast crowds of black-clad demonstrators thronged Hong Kong on Sunday in the largest anti-government protests since local elections last month that boosted the pro-democracy movement seeking to curb controls by China… It was the first time since August that the Civil Human Rights Front - organizer of million-strong marches earlier in the year… - had received authorities’ permission for a rally. It estimated turnout of 800,000 while police said 183,000.”

December 9 – Reuters: “China’s exports in November shrank for the fourth consecutive month, underscoring persistent pressures on manufacturers from the Sino-U.S. trade war but growth in imports may be a sign that Beijing’s stimulus steps are helping to stoke demand. The 17-month long trade dispute has heightened the risks of a global recession and fueled speculation that China’s policymakers could unleash more stimulus as growth in the world’s second-largest economy cooled to nearly 30-year lows. Overseas shipments fell 1.1% from a year earlier last month… China’s trade surplus for November stood at $38.73 billion, compared with an expected $46.30 billion surplus… and a $42.81 billion surplus recorded in October.”

December 8 – Associated Press (Joe McDonald): “China’s trade with the United States sank again in November as negotiators worked on the first stage of a possible deal to end a tariff war. Exports to the United States fell 23% from a year earlier to $35.6 billion… Imports of American goods were off 2.8% at $11 billion, giving China a surplus with the United States of $24.6 billion.”

Central Banking Watch:

December 8 – Bloomberg (Enda Curran): “The era of central bank shock and awe is over. More than ten years of crisis fighting -- including this year’s rush to support global growth -- have left policy makers in key economies facing a new decade with few good options to fight the next downturn. Interest rates are either already around historic lows or negative after more than 750 cuts since 2008, spurring concerns they are doing more harm than good. At the same time, leading central banks are buying bonds again -- so called quantitative easing -- after the purchase of more than $12 trillion of financial assets wasn’t enough to revive inflation.”

December 11 – Reuters (Balazs Koranyi and Francesco Canepa): “Christine Lagarde struck a more upbeat tone on the economy in her first news conference as head of the European Central Bank on Thursday and promised a new style of leadership as she outlined a sweeping one-year review of the bank’s workings. With the euro zone economy barely expanding, the former IMF chief firmly embraced the ECB’s easy money policy but suggested that the worst of the bloc’s slowdown may now over and an often-discussed but elusive recovery could now begin.”

Brexit Watch:

December 12 – Associated Press (Gregory Katz): “British Prime Minister Boris Johnson campaigned on one theme alone — ‘Get Brexit done.’ His sweeping victory in Thursday’s election means that could now happen within weeks. Even before his Conservative Party had officially crossed the winning line Friday, Johnson said it looked like his party had ‘a powerful new mandate’ to complete Britain’s divorce from the European union. Johnson now looks certain to pull Britain out of the EU by the Jan. 31 deadline, but he will still face the mountainous challenge of negotiating a complex trade deal with the EU by the end of next year — a task that many experts say is not possible.”

EM Watch:

December 12 – Bloomberg (Kartik Goyal): “Indian bonds, the worst performer this month among Asian peers, may extend losses with no let-up in the bad news facing them. The benchmark 10-year debt had sold off Wednesday evening after S&P Global Ratings warned of a downgrade, dealing a blow to an already frail sentiment. The Reserve Bank of India’s shock hold on rates last week led to the worst weekly fall in bond prices in more than one-and-a-half years. S&P’s red flag adds to lingering concerns about a wider fiscal deficit, rising inflation, volatile oil prices and the absence of bond purchases by the RBI. Retail inflation accelerated to 5.54% in November from a year earlier…”

December 6 – Bloomberg (Ronojoy Mazumdar): “India’s real estate, construction and infrastructure industries are in ‘deep trouble,’ and non-bank finance companies which lend to these sectors should have their asset quality reviewed, former central bank Governor Raghuram Rajan said. There is also ‘significant distress in rural areas,’ Rajan wrote… He said India is in a growth recession, defined as an economy growing at a slow pace and where unemployment is rising. India’s GDP growth slowed to 4.5% in the quarter ended September, a six-year low. A crisis among shadow lenders and a build-up of bad loans at banks have curbed lending in the economy.”

December 12 – Reuters (Daren Butler, Ezgi Erkoyun and Ali Kucukgocmen): “Turkey’s central bank cut its policy rate by 200 basis points to 12%... The bank lowered its benchmark one-week repo rate from 14%, bringing Turkish ‘real’ rates below the levels in most emerging markets. Economists polled by Reuters had expected a cut of 150 bps.”

Europe Watch:

December 10 – Reuters (Paul Carrel): “The ZEW research institute’s monthly index on economic morale among investors rose to 10.7 from -2.1 a month earlier. The reading exceeded even the highest forecast in a Reuters poll of economists, which showed a consensus prediction of 0.0.”

Global Bubble Watch:

December 8 – Bloomberg (Anchalee Worrachate): “The European repo market may have escaped the kind of turmoil that engulfed the U.S. financial system this year, but that doesn’t mean all is calm. The 8 trillion-euro ($9 trillion) market is becoming increasingly fragmented, according to the Bank for International Settlements. While this hasn’t caused harm yet, it raises the risk that cash may not flow through the system properly, BIS said in its quarterly review. That’s what caused chaos in the U.S. almost three months ago.”

December 8 – Bloomberg (John Ainger, Vivien Lou Chen, and Ruth Carson): “First it was Japan. Then Europe. Now investors are scanning the world for the next outbreak of stagnant inflation and tumbling yields. The malaise of ‘Japanification’ burst into the mainstream this year, leaving in its wake a record amount of negative-yielding debt. Quantitative easing and a low-rate regime in Europe delivered banner returns on the region’s bonds -- at the expense of bank profits and retirement savings. Many say it recalls Japan’s lost decade.”

Japan Watch:

December 8 – Reuters (Daniel Leussink): “Japan’s economy expanded at a much faster pace than initially reported in the third quarter, as resilient domestic demand and business spending offset the hit to growth from falling exports and global trade tensions. Gross domestic product grew an annualised 1.8% in July-September, stronger than the preliminary reading of 0.2% annualised growth…”

December 12 – Reuters (Leika Kihara and Kaori Kaneko): “Japanese big manufacturers’ business mood sank to a near seven year low in the fourth quarter, a closely watched central bank survey showed, as the U.S.-China trade war and soft global demand weighed on the export-reliant economy. Companies expect conditions to remain unchanged or even worsen three months ahead, the Bank of Japan’s ‘tankan’ quarterly survey showed, suggesting that the fallout from the trade conflict could hurt broader sectors of the economy.”

Leveraged Speculation Watch:

December 8 – Financial Times (Tommy Stubbington and Joe Rennison): “Hedge funds exacerbated the recent turmoil in the repo market with their thirst for borrowing cash to juice up returns on their trades, according to the Bank for International Settlements. Investors, bankers and policymakers were left stunned in September when the cost of borrowing cash overnight in exchange for high-quality collateral such as US government debt shot higher, eventually forcing action from the Federal Reserve to keep the market functioning smoothly.”

Geopolitical Watch:

December 7 – Reuters (Soyoung Kim, Josh Smith): “U.S. President Donald Trump said… that North Korean leader Kim Jong Un risks losing ‘everything’ if he resumes hostility and his country must denuclearize, after the North said it had carried out a ‘successful test of great significance.’ ‘Kim Jong Un is too smart and has far too much to lose, everything actually, if he acts in a hostile way. He signed a strong Denuclearization Agreement with me in Singapore,’ Trump said on Twitter…”

December 9 – Bloomberg (Jihye Lee): “North Korea took its most personal swipe at President Donald Trump in more than two years, saying the U.S. leader’s recent comments made him sound like a ‘heedless and erratic old man.’ The statement… by North Korean official Kim Yong Chol… was the latest in a rhetorical tit-for-tat ahead of Pyongyang’s self-imposed year-end deadline for a breakthrough in nuclear talks. On Sunday, Trump played down warnings from the regime, saying in a tweet that North Korean leader Kim Jong Un was ‘too smart and has far too much to lose’ to renew hostility with the U.S. ‘This naturally indicates that Trump is an old man bereft of patience,’ said Kim Yong Chol… ‘As he is such a heedless and erratic old man, the time when we can not but call him a ‘dotard’ again may come.’”

Friday Evening Links

[Reuters] Wall Street steady as U.S., China announce trade deal

[Reuters] U.S.-China trade deal swaps tariff rollbacks for farm, energy purchases

[AP] How US-China trade deal achieved a little but left out a lot

[AP] Johnson victory means Brexit is coming, tough talks loom

[CNBC] Goldman is disappointed in trade deal: Tariff rollback ‘smaller than expected’

Thursday, December 12, 2019

Friday's News Links

[Reuters] Wall St. higher on trade deal hopes; tariff deadline closes in

[Reuters] Shares and sterling soar as trade and Brexit fog lifts

[Reuters] Euro zone bonds take a beating as trade, Brexit uncertainties clear

[Reuters] Currency markets go risk-on amid trade war, Brexit optimism

[BBC] Election results 2019: PM hails Brexit 'mandate' as Tories set for big win

[AP] Johnson victory means Brexit is coming, tough talks loom

[CNBC] China to hold press briefing Friday on ‘relevant progress’ over trade talks with the US

[Reuters] U.S. sets China trade deal terms, sources say, but Beijing mum

[Reuters] U.S. retail sales rise less than expected in November

[Reuters] Senior China diplomat says U.S. seriously damaged hard-won mutual trust

[Reuters] 'Boneheads' no more? Fed's rate cuts appear to defuse Trump's Twitter rage

[Reuters] Japan business mood gloomiest in nearly seven years as trade war bites

[Bloomberg] U.S. Futures Pare Gain as Trade-Deal Doubts Emerge: Markets Wrap

[Bloomberg] Fed Aims a Half-Trillion Dollar Liquidity Hose at Year-End Risks

[Bloomberg] Trump’s China Deal Flirts With the Curse of a Phase One and Done

[Bloomberg] China’s Decade of Drama for Yuan Sets New Risks for the 2020s

[WSJ] Bond Defaults Reach Once-Safe Corners of Chinese Finance

[WSJ] Trump Agrees to Limited Trade Deal With China

[WSJ] Government Bond Yields Surge After Trump Proclaims Progress on Trade Talks

[WSJ] New York Fed Again Upsizes Liquidity Plans for Turn of the Year

[FT] Paul Volcker: his values and legacy

[FT] Repo and swaps markets point to further volatility

Thursday Evening Links

[CNBC] Sterling surges 2% as UK exit poll projects a large majority for Boris Johnson’s Conservative Party

[Bloomberg] Trump Approves U.S.-China Trade Deal to Halt Dec. 15 Tariffs

[CNBC] Boris Johnson’s Conservative Party set to win UK election with a clear majority, exit poll shows

[Reuters] China to buy $50 billion in U.S. farm products in return for tariff concessions-U.S. sources

[CNBC] Stocks rebound back toward the highs of the day on report phase one deal is reached

[Reuters] Treasuries - U.S. long-dated yield climbs to four-week peak on renewed trade optimism

[CNBC] Trump administration offers to cancel next China tariffs, cut some existing duties in half, sources say

[Reuters] U.S. offers China tariff rate cut; announcement 'imminent'

[UK Telegraph] General election 2019 live: Result 'too close to call' as voting continues - latest news

[Reuters] Repo is Wall Street's big year-end worry. Why?

[CNBC] ETF assets to surge tenfold in 10 years to $50 trillion, Bank of America predicts

[Bloomberg] Trump to Meet With Advisers on Possible China Trade Breakthrough

[Bloomberg] U.S. Business Debt Exceeds Households' for First Time Since 1991

[Bloomberg] Beijing Has Built Thousands of Cheap Apartments No One Wants

Wednesday, December 11, 2019

Thursday's News Links

[Reuters] Wall Street hits record high as trade hopes rise

[Reuters] Global stocks test record highs, pound braces for election all-nighter

[Reuters] Dollar licks wounds as Fed disappoints bulls, UK election awaited

[Reuters] High-stakes White House meeting expected Thursday to debate U.S.-China tariffs: sources

[Reuters] China says in close communication with U.S. on trade as fresh tariffs loom

[Reuters] U.S. producer prices flat; jobless claims at more than two-year high

[Reuters] United Kingdom votes to decide the fate of Brexit, again

[Reuters] Wall Street, Fed prep to avoid year end disruption in repo markets

[Reuters] 'Black Swan' index flashes yellow: Wall Street is not scared

[Reuters] ECB keeps generous stimulus unchanged in Lagarde's first meeting

[Reuters] Turkey cuts rates 200 pts as aggressive easing cycle nears end

[Reuters] Hong Kong protesters mark six months since pivotal clash with police

[Bloomberg] China Suffers Biggest Dollar Bond Default By State-Owned Company in Two Decades

[Bloomberg] Rumbling Credit Trouble Puts Risky-Loan Buyers on Alert for 2020

[Bloomberg] Americans’ Souring Credit Card Debt Poised to Reach 10-Year High

[Bloomberg] China Vehicle Sales to Fall 8% This Year in Second Straight Drop

[Bloomberg] Why China’s Debt Defaults Look Set to Pick Up Again

[Bloomberg] More Pain Looms for Asia’s Worst-Performing Bonds

[NYT] China’s Companies Binged on Debt. Now They Can’t Pay the Bill.

[NYT] Natural Gas Boom Fizzles as a U.S. Glut Sinks Profits

[WSJ] Federal Reserve Keeps Interest Rates Steady, Sees Long Pause

[FT] Expect more repo turmoil, says analyst who predicted September spike

Wednesday Evening Links

[Reuters] Wall Street posts modest gain as Fed signals rates to hold for some time

[AP] US budget deficit rises to $209 billion in November

[CNBC] Fed Decision: Interest rates left unchanged, indicates no changes through 2020

[Reuters] Fed keeps interest rates on hold amid 'favorable' economic outlook

[Reuters] Gasoline, rents lift U.S. consumer inflation in November

[AP] Leaders scramble for final votes as UK’s ugly election ends

[Bloomberg] Fed Opens Door to Buying More Than T-Bills If Needed to Fix Repo

[WSJ] Central Bank Group’s Report Points to Deeper Problems in Repo Market

Tuesday, December 10, 2019

Wednesday's News Links

[Reuters] Stocks flat with focus on tariff deadline, Fed decision

[Reuters] U.S. consumer prices increase more than expected in November

[CNBC] The Fed is expected to hold rates steady and vow to keep short-term lending markets stable

[Reuters] After year of living dangerously, Fed likely to signal time to lay low

[Reuters] Trump will have final say on U.S.-China trade deal: White House trade adviser

[CNBC] Nearly 150 CEOs departed in November, putting 2019 on track to be record year for executive exits

[Reuters] DoubleLine's Gundlach sees risk for U.S. credit when dollar weakens

[Bloomberg] Fed Dots May Yield Clue on Split Over Pause: Decision Day Guide

[Bloomberg] Wall Street’s Fear Gauge Is Acting Up. It May Signal Trouble

[Bloomberg] Traders Buy Hedges ‘Like World Is About to End’

[NYT] Signs Point to China Tariff Delay, but Decision Rests With Trump

[WSJ] China’s Yuan Punches Below Its Weight

[FT] Paul Volcker issues warning for America in final essay

[FT] China’s smaller banks forced to act to support shares

Tuesday Evening Links

[Reuters] Stocks, government debt flat as U.S.-China trade deadline looms

[Reuters] Oil rises but U.S.-China trade war weighs on demand outlook

[Reuters] Powell's 'half-full' U.S. glass sturdy but still at risk for spills as Fed meets

[Reuters] U.S., Canada and Mexico sign agreement - again - to replace NAFTA

[Reuters] Repo rupture at year-end could lead to 'QE4' - Credit Suisse analyst

[Bloomberg] Jitters Over China’s Local Defaults Start to Spread Offshore

Sunday, December 8, 2019

Monday's News Links

[Reuters] Wall Street drops after weak Chinese data; Tariff deadline looms

[Reuters] Stocks whacked as China export decline highlights trade war damage

[CNBC] Paul Volcker, the Carter-Reagan Fed chairman who beat inflation, dies at age 92

[Reuters] China says hopes it can reach trade agreement with U.S. as soon as possible

[UK Guardian] China tells government offices to remove all foreign computer equipment

[Reuters] Swelling U.S. IPO backlog points to crowded 2020 field

[Reuters] Japan upgrades third-quarter GDP as consumer, business strength absorbs hit from trade

[Reuters] Trump says Kim Jong Un risks losing 'everything' after North Korea claims major test

[Bloomberg] Repo Girds for Next Test as BIS, El-Erian Examine Crunch Causes

[Bloomberg] Beijing Orders Removal of Foreign Tech in State Offices, FT Says

[Bloomberg] China’s Latest Bond Scare Casts Doubt on a $1.3 Trillion Market

[Bloomberg] Japanification Is the Scourge Threatening to Go Global in 2020

[Bloomberg] North Korea Blasts Trump ‘Old, Erratic’ as Rhetoric Heats Up

[NYT] Paul A. Volcker, Fed Chairman Who Waged War on Inflation, Is Dead at 92

[NYT] Trump Cripples W.T.O. as Trade War Rages

[WSJ] As Tariff Deadline Looms, Investors’ Other Worries Fade Away

[WSJ] Investors Gird for Year-End Turmoil in Cash Markets

[WSJ] Junk Bonds Set for Pain if Economic Pessimists Are Right

[FT] Hedge funds key in exacerbating repo market turmoil, says BIS

[FT] New York Fed’s latest repo auction met with strong demand

Sunday Evening Links

[Reuters] Asian stocks pulled higher by Wall Street jobs rally but China caution prevails

[Reuters] Oil prices stumble on weak China exports hangover

[Reuters] China exports fall for fourth consecutive month as Beijing demands tariff rollback as part of trade deal

[CNBC] What Trump does before trade deadline is the ‘wild card’ that will drive markets in the week ahead

[Bloomberg] Repo Blowup Was Fueled by Big Banks and Hedge Funds, BIS Says

[Bloomberg] Now Repo Distortions Are Emerging in Europe’s $9 Trillion Market

[Bloomberg] Danger Lurks for Currency Market If Volatility Recurs, BIS Says

[FT] Beijing orders state offices to replace foreign PCs and software

Sunday's News Links

[Reuters] China November exports fall, but import growth hints of recovering demand

[AP] China’s trade with US sinks in November amid tariff war

[Reuters] China's potential growth below 6% over next five years: central bank adviser

[Reuters] Hong Kong sees biggest protests since democrats' election boost

[Bloomberg] The Shock and Awe Era for Central Banks Is Over

[Bloomberg] Wall Street Goes Slightly Crazy Each Weekday Afternoon. Here's Why

[Bloomberg] India’s Construction, Property Industries in Trouble, Rajan Says

[WSJ] Investors Bail on Stock Market Rally, Fleeing Funds at Record Pace

Friday, December 6, 2019

Weekly Commentary: Crazy Extremis

Dr. Bernanke has referred to the understanding of the forces behind the Great Depression as the “Holy Grail of Economics.” But was the Great Depression chiefly the consequence of post-crash policy mistakes, as conventional thinking has come profess? Was it really a case of the Federal Reserve having grossly failed in its responsibility to expand the money supply? Or did the previous “Roaring Twenties” Bubble sow the seeds of a major down-cycle and collapse?

Having in the past carefully read through Bernanke’s writings on the twenties and subsequent depression, it was clear his analysis had a fundamental flaw: it disregarded momentous market dynamics that unfolded following the creation of the Federal Reserve system and recovery after the first world war.

The unprecedented buildup of speculative leverage throughout the twenties boom played an instrumental role in systemic liquidity abundance that fueled both financial distortions and economic maladjustment. Confidence in the Federal Reserve’s capacity to sustain marketplace liquidity was instrumental in bolstering a progressively speculative market environment that culminated in the 1927 to 1929 speculative blow-off.

There are those who believe the Federal Reserve should have acted even more aggressively when subprime cracked in mid-2007. More aggressive stimulus measures (why not QE in 2007?) and a Lehman bailout would have averted the “worst financial crisis since the Great Depression,” they believe.

As the late Dr. Kurt Richebacher would often repeat, “the only cure for a Bubble is to not let it inflate.” Certainly, the longer Bubbles expand the greater the underlying fragilities – ensuring timid central bankers unwilling to risk reining in excess. This was the problem in the late-twenties and in 2006/2007. I would argue this has been a fundamental dilemma for central bankers persistently now for going on a decade. Especially after the Bernanke Fed targeted risk assets as the key system reflationary mechanism, central banks have been loath to do anything that might risk upsetting the markets. Recall the 2011 “exit strategy” – promptly scrapped in favor of another doubling of the Fed’s balance sheet to $4.5 TN (by 2014).

From my analytical perspective, things have followed the worst-case scenario now for over three decades. Alan Greenspan’s assurances and loose monetary policy after the 1987 crash spurred “decade of greed” excesses that culminated with Bubbles in junk bonds, M&A and coastal real estate. The response to severe early-nineties bank impairment and recession was aggressive monetary stimulus and the active promotion of Wall Street finance (GSEs, MBS, ABS, derivatives, hedge funds, proprietary trading, etc.).

Once the boom in highly speculative market-based Credit took hold, there was no turning back. The 1994 bond bust ensured the Fed was done with the type of rate increases that might actually impinge speculation and tighten financial conditions. The Mexican bailout guaranteed fledgling Bubbles would run wild in Southeast Asia and elsewhere. The LTCM/Russia market “bailout” ensured Bubble Dynamics turned absolutely Crazy in technology stocks and U.S. corporate Credit. Things took a turn for the worse following the “tech” Bubble collapse. With Wall Street cheering on, the Federal Reserve fatefully targeted mortgage Credit as the key mechanism for system reflation. A doubling of mortgage debt in just over six years was one of history’s more reckless monetary inflations. The panicked response to the collapsing mortgage finance Bubble fomented by far the greatest monetary inflation the world has ever experienced: China; EM; Japan; Treasury debt; central bank Credit; speculative leverage everywhere…

The “global government finance Bubble” saw egregious excess break out at the foundation of finance – central bank Credit and sovereign debt. It was a “slippery slope”; no turning back. The sordid history of inflationism has been replayed: once monetary inflation commences it becomes virtually impossible to stop. There was barely a pause following the ECB’s $2.6 TN QE program before the electronic “printing presses” were fired up again. The Fed’s balance sheet inflated from less than $1.0 TN pre-crisis to $4.5 TN. After contracting to $3.7 TN this past August, it’s now quickly back above $4.0 TN. The Bank of Japan hasn’t even attempted to rein in QE, with assets at a record $5.3 TN – up from the pre-crisis $1.0 TN.

Believing “THE” Bubble had burst in 2000, the Fed saw no basis for not aggressively “reflating.” The Fed and global central bankers were convinced “THE” Bubble collapsed in 2008. It would be reckless not to proceed with history’s greatest concerted monetary inflation. “Whatever it takes” was necessary to save the euro and European integration. Globally, the scourge of deflation has apparently been lurking around every corner – for a decade. It was imperative for the Bank of Japan to demonstrate absolute resolve.

Things got completely away from Beijing. Having studied the Japanese experience, they failed to grasp the necessity of quashing Bubble excess early. Over time, GDP targets, global power dynamics and the fear of bursting Bubbles took precedence. As it turned out, the greater their Bubble inflated the more heated the U.S./China rivalry. In theory, it seemed reasonable to let air out of the Bubble gently. In reality, powerful Bubbles only scoff. As conspicuous as debt excesses and economic maladjustment became, “structural reform” took a backseat to negotiations with Donald Trump. A key Credit Bubble adage comes to mind: There’s never a convenient time to deflate a Bubble.

My view is that Chinese financial and economic fragilities were a major contributor to this past year’s historic global yield collapse. Present a highly speculative marketplace a high probability of aggressive monetary stimulus and you’re asking for a destabilizing “blow-off.” And in this strange world in which we live, wild speculative Credit market excess (i.e. collapsing yields) is viewed by nervous central bankers as a signal to employ aggressive monetary stimulus.

November non-farm payrolls jumped 266,000, much stronger-than-expected and the largest job growth since January (41.3k returning GM workers). The jobless rate declined to 3.5% (matching low since 1969), as average hourly earnings gained 3.1% from November ’18. For a fourth consecutive month of gains, preliminary December University of Michigan Consumer Confidence jumped to (an above estimates) 99.2, the strongest reading since May (and only 2pts from the strongest reading going back to 2004). At 115.2, the reading on Current Conditions (up 10 points since August) jumped to a one-year-high.

The Fed erred in cutting rates three times this year. It was arguably a crucial policy blunder, though in all likelihood the exact opposite will be argued in the future: The Fed should have stimulated more aggressively. We can anticipate the assertion the Fed flubbed last year in raising rates. Heck, the Federal Reserve should have gone full Japanese: zero rates and QE indefinitely. The S&P500 ended the week with a year-to-date gain of 25.5%, lagging Nasdaq’s 30.5%. The Nasdaq Computer Index has jumped 43.8%, with the Semiconductors (SOX) surging 49.3%. The Banks (BKX) have enjoyed 2019 gains of 29.3%.

Markets have virtually no concern the Fed might actually reassess its policy course and reverse rate cuts (what happened to “mid-cycle adjustment”?). Markets see only a 1.7% probability of a rate increase by the June 2020 FOMC meeting, while the probability of another cut sits at 42.9%. Curiously, the bond market took Friday’s robust economic data calmly. Ten-year Treasury yields rose only three bps Friday to 1.84% (up 6bps for the week). A delayed reaction wouldn’t be surprising. Perhaps bonds are holding out hope for negative trade headlines. But an asymmetrical Fed policy bias (no rate increase at least through next November’s elections) seems for now to work for both stocks and bonds.

It’s difficult to define “Crazy”. I suppose you know it when you see it. It’s a central facet of Bubble Analysis that things get Crazy at the end of cycles. Arguing that we’re in the throes of the history’s greatest global Bubble, we shouldn’t underestimate Craziness Extremis. Bear markets and recessions have been rescinded. Stocks always go up. Debt and deficits don’t matter. The Beijing meritocracy is up to any challenge. Global central bankers have things well under control.

I’ve been thinking a lot lately about a key unheeded lesson from the mortgage finance Bubble experience: prolonged market distortions come with grave consequences. The belief that the Fed and Treasury wouldn’t tolerate a housing crisis was instrumental in the mispricing of finance that saw yields drop (prices rise) in the face of a doubling of total mortgage debt. The perception of government-imposed safety abrogated the market pricing mechanism. Supply and demand no longer dictated the price of mortgage Credit. The market became unhinged.

Over the years, I’ve described how a Bubble in high-risk junk bonds would pose limited systemic risk. If things heated up – if issuance got out of hand, the market would howl, “No More Junk!” Market discipline would essentially bring the boom to a conclusion prior to prolonged excess and the onset of deep structural maladjustment.

A Bubble financed by “money” is perilous. There is, after all, essentially unlimited demand for instruments perceived as safe and liquid stores of (nominal) value. Implied federal guarantees of GSE debt and assurance of aggressive Federal Reserve reflationary measures in the event of instability bestowed the precious attribute of moneyness to mortgage-related debt during that fateful Bubble period (“Moneyness of Credit”).

More than a decade ago I warned of the “Moneyness of Risk Assets” – with Bernanke’s reflationary measures having lavished the perception of safety and liquidity upon equities, corporate Credit and derivatives.

November 30 – Financial Times (Chris Flood): “Global assets held by exchange traded funds have climbed to a record $6tn, doubling in less than four years… The sector’s explosive growth has attracted heightened scrutiny by regulators who are concerned about the influence of ETFs as they spread deeper and wider into financial markets worldwide. ‘Passing the $6tn milestone is a historic moment but we are still in a relatively early stage of the industry’s development as ETF adoption rates across Europe and Asia are well below those seen in the US,’ said Deborah Fuhr, co-founder of ETFGI…”

And if the incredible flows into perceived safe and liquid ETF shares weren’t enough… Is this the time to run to – or away from – the bond market?

December 1 – Financial Times (Chris Flood): “Exchange traded funds linked to bond markets have attracted higher investor inflows than equivalent equity products this year in a highly unusual development in the history of the ETF industry. Bond ETFs have traditionally accounted for a fraction of the new cash entering the $5.9tn segment of the asset management world… But this pattern has reversed in 2019 for the first time. Investors have ploughed $191bn into fixed income ETFs in the first 10 months, compared with less than $158bn in new cash gathered by equity ETFs, according to ETFGI… ‘Adoption rates have accelerated noticeably as more investors have realised that fixed income ETFs can provide efficient solutions to some of the liquidity challenges of cash bond markets,’ said Deborah Fuhr, co-founder of ETFGI.”

The mortgage finance Bubble finally got into serious trouble when the “blow-off” subprime mania had driven home prices to unsustainable levels. Speculators turned cautious, financial conditions tightened, the marginal subprime buyer lost access to Credit, home prices reversed, the Bubble faltered, and the fringe of mortgage Credit lost its “moneyness.” Those highly levered in mortgage securities lost access to funding and crisis erupted. Market and economic structures having become addicted to Credit and liquidity excess were suddenly starved of both.

In a replay of the previous Bubble, government distortions have ensured a complete breakdown in market pricing mechanisms. Yields have declined (securities prices inflated) in the face of a tripling of Federal debt. And with central bank Credit and government debt fueling the Bubble, markets breathe easily. What could go wrong? There’s no subprime and home price dynamic that could bring the party to a bitter end. And as the Italian debt market has demonstrated, market concern for the quantity, quality and liquidity of sovereign debt can be alleviated through the expansion of central bank Credit (“money”).

So how might this all come to an end? Where is the current Bubble’s soft underbelly – the area of potentially acute fragility?

December 2 – Bloomberg (Yalman Onaran): “Flare-ups in the repo market could still cause worries across the global banking system, more than two months after chaos subsided in this vital corner of finance. Of particular concern: U.S. Treasuries, the world’s biggest bond market and the place where the federal government funds its escalating deficit. If repo rates become jumpy again -- and many are girding for that to happen in the middle and end of this month -- some of those leveraged investors may have to unwind Treasury holdings, potentially increasing the U.S. government’s interest costs at a time of record borrowing. ‘If repos were much harder to get at reasonable rates, Treasury prices would drop,’ said Darrell Duffie, a Stanford University finance professor who’s co-authored research on repo with Federal Reserve staffers. ‘The cost to taxpayers for funding the national debt would therefore rise.’”

Global securities funding markets could well prove a critical weak link. Over recent months, instability has erupted in China’s money markets. There have been indications of vulnerability in global dollar funding markets. And, of course, there were September’s “repo” market convulsions here at home.

The Bloomberg article noted above included the following: “As U.S. government debt rose by $1 trillion in the 12 months through March, more than 80% of it was absorbed by ‘other investors,’ a category in the U.S. Treasury Department’s latest available database that includes broker-dealers and hedge funds. In the same period, holdings by primary dealers… increased by only about $100 billion.” Another Bloomberg article (see “China Watch”) discussed China’s $4.7 TN market in local government financing vehicles (LGFV), much of this market offering relatively high interest rates. A third Bloomberg article (see “Leveraged Speculation Watch”) noted “China’s crowded market of close to 9,000 hedge funds.” These are serious problems.

Evidence and anecdotes continue to support the thesis of unprecedented global leverage having accumulated throughout this most protracted boom cycle. People’s Bank of China liquidity injections stabilized China’s money market. Federal Reserve Credit expanded $293 billion in 12 weeks, pacifying U.S. overnight “repo” funding markets. But there’s a major problem: distorted markets and central bank backstops have afforded blank checkbooks to governments around the world. The U.S. Treasury is poised to run Trillion dollar deficits as far as the eye can see. And so long as markets are fearing trade wars, recession and deflation, downward pressure on bond yields keeps the game chugging along.

Yet the possibility of a trade agreement, economic expansion and some inflationary pressures could prove problematic. Rising bond yields would put pressure on highly leveraged and vulnerable markets. In all the discussion of “repo” market issues and challenges, the key point is somehow missed: Accommodating and promoting a market that finances speculative leveraging virtually guarantees problematic Bubbles. How could this lesson not have been learned in 2008? Now it’s a global Bubble, with all the issues of financial fragility, economic maladjustment, and wealth redistribution on an unprecedented scale.

For the Week:

The S&P500 added 0.2% (up 25.5% y-t-d), while the Dow was little changed (up 20.1%). The Utilities increased 0.3% (up 19.4%). The Banks jumped 1.1% (up 29.3%), while the Broker/Dealers were unchanged (up 21.7%). The Transports fell 1.4% (up 16.8%). The S&P 400 Midcaps rose 0.6% (up 21.6%), and the small cap Russell 2000 gained 0.6% (up 21.2%). The Nasdaq100 was little changed (up 32.7%). The Semiconductors added 0.4% (up 49.3%). The Biotechs rose 1.5% (up 20.3%). With bullion rallying $16, the HUI gold index gained 1.2% (up 35.3%).

Three-month Treasury bill rates ended the week at 1.475%. Two-year government yields were little changed at 1.62% (down 87bps y-t-d). Five-year T-note yields gained four bps to 1.66% (down 85bps). Ten-year Treasury yields rose six bps to 1.84% (down 85bps). Long bond yields jumped seven bps to 2.28% (down 74bps). Benchmark Fannie Mae MBS yields gained three bps to 2.73% (down 76bps).

Greek 10-year yields rose six bps to 1.49% (down 291bps y-t-d). Ten-year Portuguese yields increased two bps 0.42% (down 130bps). Italian 10-year yields surged 12 bps to 1.35% (down 139bps). Spain's 10-year yields jumped eight bps to 0.49% (down 92bps). German bund yields gained seven bps to negative 0.29% (down 53bps). French yields jumped eight bps to 0.03% (down 68bps). The French to German 10-year bond spread widened one to 32 bps. U.K. 10-year gilt yields rose eight bps to 0.77% (down 51bps). U.K.'s FTSE equities index dropped 1.5% (up 7.6% y-t-d).

Japan's Nikkei Equities Index added 0.3% (up 16.7% y-t-d). Japanese 10-year "JGB" yields jumped seven to negative 0.01% (down 7bps y-t-d). France's CAC40 dipped 0.6% (up 24.1%). The German DAX equities index declined 0.5% (up 24.7%). Spain's IBEX 35 equities index added 0.3% (up 9.9%). Italy's FTSE MIB index slipped 0.3% (up 26.5%). EM equities were mixed. Brazil's Bovespa index rallied 2.7% (up 22.1%), while Mexico's Bolsa dropped 2.1% (up 0.7%). South Korea's Kospi index declined 0.3% (up 2.0%). India's Sensex equities index fell 0.9% (up 12.1%). China's Shanghai Exchange rose 1.4% (up 16.8%). Turkey's Borsa Istanbul National 100 index gained 1.8% (up 19.3%). Russia's MICEX equities index slipped 0.2% (up 23.6%).

Investment-grade bond funds saw inflows of $2.233 billion, while junk bond funds posted outflows of $154 million (from Lipper).

Freddie Mac 30-year fixed mortgage rates were unchanged at 3.68% (down 107bps y-o-y). Fifteen-year rates slipped a basis point to 3.14% (down 107bps). Five-year hybrid ARM rates fell four bps to 3.39% (down 68bps). Bankrate's survey of jumbo mortgage borrowing costs had 30-year fixed rates down ten bps to 3.92% (down 79bps).

Federal Reserve Credit last week increased $17.5bn to $4.019 TN, with a 12-week gain of $293 billion. Over the past year, Fed Credit contracted $28.5bn, or 0.7%. Fed Credit inflated $1.208 Trillion, or 43%, over the past 369 weeks. Elsewhere, Fed holdings for foreign owners of Treasury, Agency Debt gained $2.0 billion last week to $3.417 TN. "Custody holdings" were up $13 billion, or 0.4% y-o-y.

M2 (narrow) "money" supply jumped $38.5 billion last week to a record $15.364 TN. "Narrow money" rose $1.085 TN, or 7.6%, over the past year. For the week, Currency increased $2.0bn. Total Checkable Deposits jumped $37.3bn, and Savings Deposits gained $17.8bn. Small Time Deposits dipped $3.0bn. Retail Money Funds fell $15.7bn.

Total money market fund assets added $2.4bn to $3.579 TN. Money Funds gained $635bn y-o-y, or 21.6%.

Total Commercial Paper declined $2.7bn to $1.136 TN. CP was up $60bn, or 5.6% year-over-year.

Currency Watch:

The U.S. dollar index declined 0.6% to 97.70 (up 1.6% y-t-d). For the week on the upside, the Brazilian real increased 2.4%, the New Zealand dollar 2.2%, the British pound 1.7%, the Mexican peso 1.2%, the Australian dollar 1.2%, the Norwegian krone 1.0%, the Swiss franc 0.9%, the Japanese yen 0.8%, the Swedish krona 0.8%, the Singapore dollar 0.5%, the euro 0.4%, the South African rand 0.3%, and the Canadian dollar 0.2%. On the downside, the South Korean won declined 0.7%. The Chinese renminbi declined 0.04% versus the dollar this week (down 2.22% y-t-d).

Commodities Watch:

The Bloomberg Commodities Index rallied 1.5% this week (up 1.6% y-t-d). Spot Gold recovered 1.1% to $1,460 (up 13.9%). Silver dropped 3.0% to $16.596 (up 6.8%). WTI crude surged $4.03 to $59.20 (up 30%). Gasoline rallied 3.5% (up 25%), and Natural Gas gained 2.3% (down 21%). Copper jumped 2.4% (up 4%). Wheat sank 3.2% (up 4%). Corn fell 1.2% (up 1%).

Market Instability Watch:

December 4 – CNBC (Fred Imbert): “The stock market’s poor start to December halted in its tracks the kind of euphoric rally that has marked the end of past bull markets, a so-called blow-off top. Between mid-August and late November, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was up 10.5% in a 74-day sprint that seemed to be immune from negative headlines. According to Ned Davis Research, the Dow has posted a median gain of 13.4% during blow-off tops dating to 1901. The median rally length was 61 days. ‘Given the high valuations I see, plus these divergences between many different indices, I am aware that many bull markets have ended with a rally similar to what we have seen since August,’ firm founder Ned Davis said…”

December 4 – Bloomberg (Vivien Lou Chen): “DoubleLine Capital… agrees with the International Monetary Fund that U.S. dollar loans made by foreign banks are creating a risk for the global financial system. Banks based outside the U.S. can’t get enough dollars to satisfy demand for loans denominated in the American currency. Unlike their U.S. counterparts, they don’t have a stable base of dollar deposits so they use foreign-currency swaps, which the IMF says are expensive and occasionally unreliable, to meet borrowers’ needs as a last resort. The trouble, according to DoubleLine, is that hiccups in this complicated arrangement -- say, increased volatility that causes sources of dollar funding to dry up -- could harm the global economy.”

December 2 – Yahoo Finance (Julie La Roche): “Influential bond investor Jeffrey Gundlach… sees a scenario where U.S. stocks get crushed in the next recession — and likely won't recover for quite some time to come. Even with Wall Street benchmarks just days removed from new record highs, the bearish investor declared that ‘the pattern of the United States outperforming the rest the world has already come to an end.’ …Gundlach noted that 2019 was one of the ‘easiest’ years ever for investors in ‘just about anything... Just throw a dart, and you're up 15-20%, not just the United States, but global stocks as well.’”

December 4 – Bloomberg (Elena Popina): “An unusual sense of tranquility has descended on China’s financial markets. The country’s stocks and government bonds have slowed to a crawl. The Shanghai Composite Index reached lows in volatility unseen in nearly two years, while the benchmark 10-year bond yield is moving in the narrowest range since 2012. And despite some drama for the yuan this week, implied volatility remains near the lowest since August. That everything should go quiet while markets elsewhere in the world swing on each new development in the trade war is especially surprising to China watchers. Some have started to question whether Beijing is acting to limit volatility in its markets, something authorities have a history of doing. While there’s no clear evidence of direct intervention in equities or the yuan, state media has recently come out in support of the stock market.”

Trump Administration Watch:

December 3 – Wall Street Journal (Bob Davis and Lingling Wei): “President Trump said he was willing to wait until after next year’s presidential election to strike a limited trade deal with China, sending stock prices down and casting doubt on whether the two sides will find enough common ground to head off new tariffs. ‘In some ways, I think it’s better to wait until after the election, you want to know the truth,’ Mr. Trump said… Mr. Trump’s remarks probably indicated an effort to gain leverage during the last two weeks before a Dec. 15 deadline for new tariffs on consumer goods to take effect, rather than signaling a fundamental breakdown in talks, said U.S. officials and close allies of Mr. Trump.”

December 4 – Reuters (Steve Holland, Costas Pitas and James Davey): “U.S. President Donald Trump said… that trade talks with China were going ‘very well,’ sounding more positive than on Tuesday when he said a trade deal might have to wait until after the 2020 U.S. presidential election. ‘Discussions are going very well and we’ll see what happens,’ Trump told reporters…”

December 3 – Reuters (David Shepardson): “U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross said… the Trump administration has not ruled out imposing tariffs on imported autos, after letting a review period end in November with no action.”

December 3 – Bloomberg (Daniel Flatley): “The U.S. House of Representatives overwhelmingly approved legislation that would impose sanctions on Chinese officials over human rights abuses against Muslim minorities, prompting Beijing to threaten possible retaliation just as the world’s two largest economies seek to close a trade deal.”

December 3 – Financial Times (Editorial Board): “Donald Trump has opened two new fronts against supposed allies in his trade war. He announced on Monday that Brazil and Argentina would lose exemptions from higher tariffs on steel and aluminium. Most worrying, however, is the disclosure that France could face 100% tariffs over its digital services tax, which aims to ensure tech companies — often American — pay their fair share of corporation tax.”

December 2 – Reuters (Andrea Shalal and Gabriel Stargardter): “U.S. President Donald Trump ambushed Brazil and Argentina…, announcing tariffs on U.S. steel and aluminum imports from the two countries in a measure that shocked South American officials and left them scrambling for answers. In an early morning tweet, Trump said the tariffs, ‘effective immediately,’ were necessary because ‘Brazil and Argentina have been presiding over a massive devaluation of their currencies. which is not good for our farmers.’”

December 2 – Reuters (Michel Rose and Estelle Shirbon): “U.S. President Donald Trump and French leader Emmanuel Macron clashed over the future of NATO on Tuesday before a summit intended to celebrate the 70th anniversary of the Western military alliance… In sharp exchanges underlining discord in a transatlantic bloc hailed by backers as the most successful military pact in history, Trump demanded that Europe pay more for its collective defense and make concessions to U.S. interests on trade.”

December 2 – Reuters (Sudip Kar-Gupta and Leigh Thomas): “France and the European Union said… they were ready to retaliate if U.S. President Donald Trump acted on a threat to impose duties of up to 100% on imports of champagne, handbags and other French products worth $2.4 billion.”

December 3 – Reuters (Alexandra Alper): “The Trump administration considered banning China’s Huawei from the U.S. financial system earlier this year as part of a host of policy options to thwart the blacklisted telecoms equipment giant, according to three people… The plan, which was ultimately shelved, called for placing Huawei Technologies Co Ltd, the world’s second largest smartphone producer, on the Treasury Department’s Specially Designated Nationals (SDN) list.”

December 1 – The Hill (Albert Hunt): “In the old days, a decade or so ago, Democrats would have assailed Donald Trump's failure on federal deficits; instead of eliminating it, as promised, the deficit has doubled to a trillion dollars as far as the eye can see. Republicans would be in full fury over the spending schemes of Democratic presidential candidates; even the mainstream moderates propose huge increases for health care, education and the social safety net for the disadvantaged. Yet deficits, as a political issue, are dead.”

Federal Reserve Watch:

December 1 – Financial Times (Brendan Greeley): “The Federal Reserve is considering introducing a rule that would let inflation run above its 2% target, a potentially significant shift in its interest rate policy. The Fed’s year-long review of its monetary policy tools is due to conclude next year and… the central bank is considering a promise that when it misses its inflation target, it will then temporarily raise that target, to make up for lost inflation. The idea would be to avoid entrenching low US price growth which has consistently undershot its goal. If the Fed adopts this so-called ‘make-up strategy’, it would mark the biggest shift in how it carries out its interest rate policy since it began to target 2% inflation in 2012.”

December 2 – Wall Street Journal (Michael S. Derby): “The Federal Reserve Bank of New York again saw very strong demand for liquidity aimed at helping financial markets navigate the turn of the year. The demand once again arrived as the Fed added temporary liquidity to financial markets Monday. All together the central bank pumped in $97.9 billion in two parts. One was via overnight repurchase agreements, or repos, that totaled $72.9 billion. The other was via 42-day repos.”

December 4 – Bloomberg (Jesse Hamilton): “The repo turmoil that put traders on edge in September has prompted a full scale review by regulators, who identified disruptions to short-term funding markets as a potential risk to the U.S. financial system. The Financial Stability Oversight Council is calling for federal agencies to collect data and scrutinize cleared repurchase transactions to determine what prompted rates to spike three months ago… The group, led by Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, highlighted the examination in its annual report… Since the disruption, bankers have complained that excessive regulation might be a factor. JPMorgan… Chief Executive Officer Jamie Dimon said Oct. 15 that his bank had the money and inclination to step in, but was prevented from doing so by liquidity rules.”

December 4 – Financial Times (Kiran Stacey and Laura Noonan): “Stress tests designed to make banks more stable might have exacerbated a spike in short-term borrowing costs that forced the Federal Reserve to step in to calm markets earlier this year, according to the lead banking regulator in the US. Randal Quarles, the vice-chair of the Fed, said… that banks’ own internal stress testing may have led them to hoard cash rather than lending it in the overnight repurchase — or repo — market. He listed these liquidity stress tests, typically carried out under the supervision of regulators stationed at the banks, as one potential cause of the crunch in September, when overnight interest rates suddenly soared.”

U.S. Bubble Watch:

December 6 – Bloomberg (Katia Dmitrieva): “U.S. job gains roared back in November as unemployment matched a half-century low and wages topped estimates, giving the Federal Reserve more reason to hold interest rates steady after three straight cuts. Payrolls jumped 266,000, the most since January, after an upwardly revised 156,000 advance the prior month, according to a Labor Department release Friday that topped all estimates in a Bloomberg survey calling for 180,000 jobs.”

December 5 – Financial Times (Lauren Fedor and Billy Ehrenberg-Shannon): “Nearly two-thirds of Americans say this year’s record-setting Wall Street rally has had little or no impact on their personal finances... A poll of likely voters for the Financial Times and the Peter G Peterson Foundation found 61% of Americans said stock market movements had little or no effect on their financial wellbeing. Thirty-nine per cent said stock market performance had a ‘very strong’ or ‘somewhat strong’ impact. The survey suggested most Americans are not aware of market movements, with just 40% of respondents correctly saying the stock market had increased in value in 2019.”

December 3 – Bloomberg (Spencer Soper): “U.S. shoppers spent $9.4 billion online on Cyber Monday -- up almost 20% from a year ago and a record -- boosting an already robust holiday shopping season. Adobe Inc., which tracks transactions across 80 of the top 100 U.S. online retailers, said almost a third of Cyber Monday sales happened on smartphones.”

December 4 – Wall Street Journal (Akane Otani): “Investors who have shrugged off tepid earnings growth this year have leaned on the argument that the majority of S&P 500 companies have wound up beating analysts’ expectations. Morgan Stanley’s wealth-management unit isn’t sold on that argument. The money manager found in an analysis of earnings that more than a third of S&P 500 companies have posted a year-over-year decline in earnings in 2019. The last times the share of companies posting contracting earnings was that high: 2009, 2008 and 2002, all periods when the broader economy, plus the stock market, were in decline.”

December 2 – Bloomberg (Lu Wang): “Wall Street analysts are slashing projections for fourth-quarter earnings at a furious pace, making it more likely that a profit recession will hit Corporate America for the first time in almost four years. Two months into the quarter, analysts have shaved 4% off their estimates to $41.12 a share, a drop of almost 1% compared with a year ago after a 1.3% decline last quarter. While they almost always lower expectations as a period progresses the current pace has been exceeded only twice since 2015.”

December 2 – Bloomberg (Anchalee Worrachate and John Gittelsohn): “Investors plowing cash into private assets may recall the words of Wall Street legend Barton Biggs: There’s no asset class that too much money can’t spoil. One of the most fertile grounds for funds harvesting returns in a world of negative-yielding bonds and expensive public companies -- private equity -- is being swamped. Historically high valuations for leveraged buyouts has the likes of Morgan Stanley Wealth Management saying the industry has hit its peak after generating a decade of double-digit returns. That’s put the managers of vast pots of Californian retirement savings in a quandary. ‘Returns are coming down,” said Elliot Hentov, head of policy research at State Street Global Advisors. ‘A lot of money is going into that space and we are seeing excess returns shrinking.’”

December 1 – Wall Street Journal (Miriam Gottfried): “U.S. private-equity firms, armed with a record amount of cash, are struggling to find ways to spend it. A year ago, fears of an economic slowdown and worries about trade tensions with China sent a tremor through markets and put some leveraged buyouts on hold. But while stocks rebounded in the new year, buyout activity never fully recovered. The aggregate value of U.S. buyouts fell 25% year to date through October, compared with the same period a year earlier, according to… Preqin. Deals totaled $155.2 billion during the first 10 months of the year—the lowest since 2014.”

December 2 – Bloomberg (David Wethe and Kevin Crowley): “The throttling back of fracking in the world’s biggest shale patch is hitting the unemployment line in Texas… Employment in the Permian Basin of West Texas has fallen by 400 through the first 10 months of the year, a massive change from the 16,700 jobs added in the same period last year, according to… the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. Permian Basin frack crews, who are brought in to complete the final stage for creating a new oil well, have dropped 21% so far this year…”

December 4 – Reuters (Karen Pierog): “Illinois’ growing unfunded pension liability, which increased by $3.8 billion to $137.3 billion at the end of fiscal 2019, underscores the need for state action to boost funding or cut costs, analysts said… The increase was fueled by actuarially insufficient state contributions and lower-than-expected investment returns… Illinois has the lowest credit ratings among U.S. states at a notch or two above the junk level due to its huge unfunded pension liability and chronic structural budget deficit.”

December 3 – Wall Street Journal (Konrad Putzier): “When it comes to real estate, the Second City sits at the bottom of the table. The value of Chicago property has been mixed in recent years, while values in New York, Boston and San Francisco have been steadily rising thanks to strong economies and job growth. Prices of office buildings, apartment properties, retail centers and industrial real estate in Chicago fell by 4.1% over the past year, according to… Real Capital Analytics. That was the worst performance among major metropolitan areas analyzed by the company, behind even crisis-stricken Hong Kong, where prices fell 2.6%.”

December 2 – Wall Street Journal (Ben Eisen): “Credit unions, long seen as a humdrum corner of consumer finance, are going toe-to-toe with the biggest financial institutions. Credit unions’ assets have grown at nearly twice the pace of banks’ over the past decade, and the cooperatives are buying small banks in record numbers. One recently partnered with Google on its plans to create a checking account.”

China Watch:

December 4 – Reuters (Gabriel Crossley and Yawen Chen): “Tariffs must be cut if China and the United States are to reach an interim agreement on trade, the Chinese commerce ministry said…, sticking to its stance that some U.S. tariffs must be rolled back for a phase one deal. ‘The Chinese side believes that if the two sides reach a phase one deal, tariffs should be lowered accordingly,’ ministry spokesman Gao Feng told reporters, adding that both sides were maintaining close communication.”

December 4 – Bloomberg (Jenny Leonard and Shuping Niu): “The U.S. and China are moving closer to agreeing on the amount of tariffs that would be rolled back in a phase-one trade deal despite tensions over Hong Kong and Xinjiang, people familiar with the talks said. The people… said that U.S. President Donald Trump’s comments Tuesday downplaying the urgency of a deal shouldn’t be understood to mean the talks were stalling, as he was speaking off the cuff. Recent U.S. legislation seeking to sanction Chinese officials over human-rights issues in Hong Kong and Xinjiang are unlikely to impact the talks, one person familiar with Beijing’s thinking said.”

December 3 – Reuters (Se Young Lee and David Brunnstrom): “China warned on Wednesday that U.S. legislation calling for a tougher response to Beijing’s treatment of its Uighur Muslim minority will affect bilateral cooperation, clouding prospects for a near-term deal to end a trade war.”

December 1 – Reuters (Cate Cadell, Idrees Ali, David Brunnstrom and Matt Spetalnick): “China… banned U.S. military ships and aircraft from visiting Hong Kong and slapped sanctions on several U.S. non-government organizations for allegedly encouraging anti-government protesters in the city to commit violent acts. The measures were a response to U.S. legislation passed last week supporting the protests which have rocked the Asian financial hub for six months… ‘We urge the U.S. to correct the mistakes and stop interfering in our internal affairs. China will take further steps if necessary to uphold Hong Kong’s stability and prosperity and China’s sovereignty,’ Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said…”

November 30 – Bloomberg: “China’s central bank governor sounded a cautious tone on the health of the global economy, while signaling that the nation’s monetary policy makers will continue to refrain from large-scale easing steps. Policy should be prepared for a ‘mid- and long-distance race’ and stick to a conventional approach as long as possible, according to the article by Governor Yi Gang… ‘The world’s economic downturn will likely stay for a long time,’ Yi wrote. ‘We should stay focused and targeted, while not competitively lowering interest rates to zero or engaging in quantitative easing’… In Sunday’s article, Yi extensively reviewed the history of global monetary policy since the Great Depression. He said overly loose policy can harm long-term development, because it delays necessary reforms and fuels bubbles.”

December 3 – Bloomberg (Hong Shen and Molly Dai): “China is hurtling toward another record year of onshore bond defaults, testing the government’s ability to keep financial markets stable as the economy slows and companies struggle to cope with unprecedented levels of debt. At least 15 defaults since the start of November have pushed this year’s total to 120.4 billion yuan ($17.1bn), within a hair’s breadth of the 121.9 billion yuan annual record in 2018…”

December 5 – Financial Times (Sun Yu and Xinning Liu): “Chinese private companies are defaulting on their debt obligations even after receiving government bailouts, raising questions over Beijing’s efforts to rescue listed groups using public funds. Beijing last year launched one of the largest state-led campaigns to save troubled private sector businesses after falling stock prices hit so-called equity pledge financing, which enables companies to borrow using their own shares as collateral. Of 339 listed private companies that have received government funding since the rescue campaign began in August 2018, 75 later reneged on payments…”

December 2 – Bloomberg (Shen Hong and Tongjian Dong): “Two Chinese companies failed to repay bonds worth a combined half a billion dollars on Monday, underscoring rising debt risks in the highly leveraged nation as the economy slows. Peking University Founder Group was unable to secure sufficient funding to repay a 270-day, 2 billion yuan ($285 million) bond… Tunghsu Optoelectronic Technology Co. failed to deliver repayment on both interest and principal on a 1.7 billion yuan bond… The quickening speed of bond defaults in China, especially among ailing private firms, highlights the growing financial strain triggered by the country’s worst economic slowdown in three decades”

December 1 – Bloomberg: “The latest bond default by a Chinese industrial group at the epicenter of a regional debt storm is escalating concerns about a cluster of private firms entangled in risky financing. Shandong-based Xiwang Group Co., which failed to make good on a delayed repayment on a local bond, is scrambling to refinance and avoid deeper trouble after triggering cross-default clauses on other bonds.”

December 5 – Bloomberg: “One corner of China’s bond market is offering yields that seem too good to be true. And, indeed, it’s permeated with ‘fakes.’ Since 2009, off-balance-sheet shell companies set up by Chinese municipalities have been selling debt to fund infrastructure projects. Called local government financing vehicles, or LGFVs, they were initially intended to supplement the stimulus Beijing launched to rescue China’s economy after the 2008 credit crisis. In the past 10 years these vehicles have amassed a huge pile of debt: 33 trillion yuan ($4.7 trillion), according to S&P Global Ratings. Of that, about 8.3 trillion yuan, or $1.2 trillion, is in bonds… The average coupon of outstanding LGFV notes was 3.9% in October, while the average for yuan-denominated corporate bonds was 3.0%... Of China’s 3.6 trillion yuan of bonds that paid more than 6% at the end of September, about 45% was issued by LGFVs.”

December 3 – Reuters (Gaurav Dogra and Brenda Goh): “Capital investment by Chinese firms has ground to its slowest pace in three years, as a weakening economy, tight credit and prolonged trade war with the United States dent sales growth and cash reserves, a Reuters analysis showed. Companies are also spending more days to turn inventory into sales and eking out smaller profit gains…, with many analysts expecting the slowdown to intensify… Chinese firms raised capital spending by 1.6% in the three months through September versus the same period a year prior…”

December 1 – Reuters (Yawen Chen and Kevin Yao): “China’s factory activity showed surprising signs of improvement in November, with growth picking up to a near three-year high, a private sector survey showed on Monday, reinforcing upbeat government data released over the weekend.”

December 3 – Reuters (Gabriel Crossley): “Activity in China’s services sector accelerated to a seven-month high in November, as new business, especially new export business, picked up, a private survey showed… Beijing has been counting on the services sector, which accounts for more than half of China’s economy, to partly offset sluggish domestic and global demand for manufactured products as a prolonged trade war with the United States drags on. The Caixin/Markit services purchasing managers’ index (PMI) rose to 53.5 last month, the quickest pace since April, from 51.1 in October.”

December 3 – Financial Times (Kate Youde): “House price growth in China is expected to slow next year to its lowest rate in five years. Ten property analysts and economists, surveyed by Reuters, estimated prices would rise 3.1% in the 12 months to December 2020, the slowest growth since the 1.8% increase recorded in 2015. The volume of sales was predicted to fall 3% next year.”

December 4 – Bloomberg: “A Chinese stock closed below its listing price on debut for the first time in seven years, showing how weak investor sentiment has become. Luoyang Jianlong Micro-Nano New Materials Co. fell 2.2% on Shanghai’s Star board Wednesday, the first mainland listing to flop on opening day since Haixin Foods Co. plunged 8% in October 2012…”

December 3 – Reuters (Cheng Leng and Engen Tham): “Postal Savings Bank of China said investors had opted out of paying for 3% of shares on offer in its Shanghai listing - a rare development that underscores growing concerns over problems in China’s banking system.”

Central Banking Watch:

December 3 – Bloomberg (Jana Randow and Alexander Weber): “The European Central Bank just received a hint that traditional German views on monetary policy will continue to feature prominently in its internal debate. Isabel Schnabel, the country’s nominee for a seat on the ECB’s Executive Board, said at her confirmation hearing in Brussels that she would probably have opposed restarting quantitative easing had she been a policy maker in September. That decision was one of the most contentious taken under former President Mario Draghi, with opposition from officials covering more than half the euro-area economy.”

EM Watch:

December 4 – Financial Times (Jonathan Wheatley): “An old fear is again stalking emerging markets — contagion. Unlike the Russian and Asian crises that engulfed the emerging world in the 1990s, contagion this time is not primarily a financial market phenomenon. Instead, it has spread through street protests in Latin America that have spooked investors. The trouble started in Brazil on November 6… This gave some investors the excuse they wanted to sell the Brazilian real, with rising risk aversion brought on by weakness across EMs… In the background, however, a bigger crisis was brewing. Street protests had been building in Chile since late October. A popular uprising in Bolivia was growing. Social and political unrest had been stirring elsewhere, in Ecuador, Peru, Brazil and Central America, not to mention crisis-stricken Venezuela. Things came to a head in the second week of November, when Chile’s protests turned increasingly violent. On November 11, Evo Morales, Bolivia’s leftwing president for almost 14 years, stood down.”

Europe Watch:

December 6 – Associated Press (Angela Charlton and Mstyslav Chernov): “Frustrated travelers are meeting transportation chaos around France for a second day on Friday, as unions dig in for what they hope is a protracted strike against President Emmanuel Macron’s plans to redesign the national retirement system. Most French trains were at a halt - including Paris subways - and traffic jams multiplied around the country.”

December 1 – Reuters (Holger Hansen and Andreas Rinke): “The future of Germany’s ruling coalition looked shaky after the election of new leaders of the Social Democrats (SPD) who are demanding a shift in policies, and several senior conservatives on Sunday ruled out talks to renegotiate a governing agreement. Two strong leftist critics of the coalition with Chancellor Angela Merkel’s conservatives - Norbert Walter-Borjans and Saskia Esken - won a vote for leadership of the Social Democrats on Saturday, possibly putting the country… at a political crossroads.”

December 3 – Wall Street Journal (Tom Fairless and Patricia Kowsmann): “On a recent morning in the spa town of Baden-Baden, children clutching piggy banks and bags stuffed with coins flooded into the local savings bank, or Sparkasse, for a lesson in frugality. The ritual has taken place across Germany every year since the International Savings Banks Institute launched World Thrift Day in 1924 to promote basic financial literacy, starting with the central tenet: Don’t ever spend more than you earn. Today, saving is viewed in Germany as a tradition and a virtue. This goes for consumers, who are stashing cash in mattresses and checking accounts…”

Global Bubble Watch:

November 29 – Bloomberg (Finbarr Flynn): “An unprecedented frenzy of debt sales around the world is threatening to cool this year’s hot returns on corporate bonds. Companies have sold a record $2.44 trillion so far this year across currencies, surpassing previous full-year records. Investors rushed to snap up all this debt because they were desperate for yield as central banks cut rates. That has pushed up valuations.”

November 29 – Bloomberg (Michael Hytha): “A surge of global deals in the past week has helped put mergers and acquisitions on track to approach and perhaps even top last year’s totals. Globally, 2019 is already the sixth-best year of the past 20… The 26,321 pending and completed transactions announced this year total $2.73 trillion, compared with 30,225 amounting to $3.07 trillion in 2018… Cross-border acquisitions of U.S. targets are down, with the total value of deals so far this year shrinking 23% to $334 billion from the same period in 2018…”

December 5 – Bloomberg (Stefania Spezzati): “Moody’s… downgraded its outlook for global banks, citing slowing growth, low interest rates and volatile operating conditions. The ratings firm changed its outlook on the sector to negative from stable… Trade tensions between the U.S. and China ‘appear entrenched, with negative consequences for banks in those countries as well as in other export-oriented economies and for banks funding trade,’ Moody’s said. Moody’s said a rising recession risk in the U.S. and Europe, along with slowing growth in Asia Pacific and emerging markets, ‘will lead to deteriorating loan quality and higher loan-loss provisioning costs for banks.’ Political risk will also be a significant source of uncertainty, it added.”

December 1 – Financial Times (Jennifer Thompson): “More than a decade of ultra-loose monetary policy has damaged the prospects of a safe retirement for millions and is sowing the seeds of the next financial crisis, according to new research. Quantitative easing… has ‘inexorably inflated’ global debt, according to almost four in five pension funds surveyed by consultancy Create Research and Amundi Asset Management. More than half (55%) of the 153 European pension plans with €1.9tn in assets surveyed believe it will be a factor in the next financial crisis.”

December 1 – Bloomberg (Emily Cadman): “Australia’s property frenzy is back in full swing, with home prices surging the most in 16 years in November. National property values jumped 1.7% last month, the largest gain since 2003, according to… CoreLogic… Sydney and Melbourne continued to lead the rebound, with prices up 2.7% and 2.2% respectively. Annualized gains over the past three months in both cities are tracking in the mid-20% range… At that rate, home values will recoup all their losses from the recent downturn and be back at record highs early next year.”

Japan Watch:

December 5 – Bloomberg (Toru Fujioka, Yoshiaki Nohara, and Takashi Hirokawa): “Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzo Abe announced stimulus measures to support growth in an economy contending with an export slump, natural disasters and the fallout from a recent sales tax increase. The total stimulus package amounts to around 26 trillion yen ($239bn) spread over the coming years… The stimulus will boost growth in the economy by about 1.4 percentage point, the document said.”

Fixed-Income Bubble Watch:

November 29 – Washington Post (David Lynch): “Little more than a decade after consumers binged on inexpensive mortgages that helped bring on a global financial crisis, a new debt surge - this time by major corporations - threatens to unleash fresh turmoil. A decade of historically low interest rates has allowed companies to sell record amounts of bonds to investors, sending total U.S. corporate debt to nearly $10 trillion, or a record 47% of the overall economy. In recent weeks, the Federal Reserve, the International Monetary Fund and major institutional investors such as BlackRock and American Funds all have sounded the alarm about the mounting corporate obligations.”

Leveraged Speculation Watch:

December 3 – Bloomberg (Charlotte Ryan): “The euro is encroaching on the dollar’s territory as the world’s currency of global borrowing, but that doesn’t mean anyone wants to keep hold of it. ‘No one wants to hold euro cash as an asset anymore but everyone wants it as a liability,’ George Saravelos, Deutsche Bank AG’s global head of currency research, wrote… As a result, the euro zone ‘is emerging as the new global provider of liquidity to the international financial system, slowly replacing the dollar,’ he said. The common currency is increasingly being used in international borrowing, inter-bank funding and cross-border carry trades. This helps subdue the euro during periods of risk appetite, but could contribute to volatility and a rise in the currency when risk aversion returns. The carry trade involves borrowing in a low-yielding currency and putting the money into others with higher interest rates, or other assets with stronger returns. It works well when volatility is low.”

November 29 – Bloomberg: “Three years after China opened its 2.5 trillion yuan ($355bn) hedge fund market to global asset managers, the industry is discovering just how hard it is to win over the country’s investors. BlackRock Inc., Man Group Plc and 20 other foreign firms licensed to run Chinese hedge funds… amassed around 5.8 billion yuan of assets as a group till August, according to… Shenzhen PaiPaiWang Investment & Management Co. The meager haul -- amounting to 0.2% of hedge fund assets in China -- reflects a host of challenges. International names like BlackRock don’t resonate much in China’s crowded market of close to 9,000 hedge funds, which has its own set of local stars.”

Geopolitical Watch:

December 5 – Reuters (James Mackenzie): “World food prices rose strongly in November, lifted by big jumps in prices of meat and vegetable oils, despite slightly lower cereals prices, the United Nations food agency said… The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) food price index, which measures monthly changes for a basket of cereals, oilseeds, dairy products, meat and sugar hit a 26-month high in November, averaging 177.2 points, up 2.7% on the previous month and up 9.5% year-on-year.”

December 4 – Reuters (Andrea Shalal): “China’s envoy to the United States… said the two countries were trying to resolve their differences over trade, but he warned of forces that he said were trying to drive a wedge between the two… Ambassador Cui Tiankai, speaking at a dinner hosted by the US-China Business Council, said U.S.-Chinese ties were at a critical crossroads due to trade frictions, but it was possible to return to a better path. ‘At the same time, we must be alert that some destructive forces are taking advantage of the ongoing trade friction (through) extreme rhetoric such as ‘decoupling,’ the ‘new Cold War,’ and ‘clash of civilizations,’’ Cui said.”

December 1 – Wall Street Journal (Georgi Kantchev): “An 1,800-mile pipeline is set to begin delivering Russian natural gas to China on Monday. The $55 billion channel is a feat of energy infrastructure—and political engineering. Russia’s most significant energy project since the collapse of the Soviet Union, the Power of Siberia pipeline is a physical bond strengthening a new era of cooperation between two world powers that have separately challenged the U.S. Beijing and Moscow, after years of rivalry and mutual suspicion, are expanding an economic and strategic partnership influencing global politics, trade and energy markets. At the same time, Beijing is fighting a trade war with Washington, and Russia’s relations with the West grow colder. ‘China and Russia joining forces sends a message that there are alternatives to the U.S.-led global order,’ said Erica Downs, a Columbia University fellow and former CIA energy analyst.”

December 3 – Reuters (Robin Emmott and Andreas Rinke): “NATO leaders set aside public insults ranging from ‘delinquent’ to ‘brain dead’ and ‘two-faced’ on Wednesday, declaring at a 70th anniversary summit they would stand together against a common threat from Russia and prepare for China’s rise. Officials insisted the summit was a success… But the meeting began and ended in acrimony startling even for the era of U.S. President Donald Trump, who arrived declaring the French president ‘nasty’ and left calling Canada’s prime minister ‘two-faced’ for mocking him on a hot mic.”

December 4 – Reuters (Phil Stewart and Robin Emmott): “Seventy years since its Cold War-era founding as a transatlantic alliance focused on Moscow, NATO is expanding its gaze toward the increasingly muscular challenge posed by China. But it is unclear, even to diplomats within the 29-member military alliance, whether NATO is up to the task - especially at a time of intense internal divisions and acrimony that were on full display heading into this week’s summit.”

December 1 – Reuters (Ben Blanchard): “Taiwan plans to invite U.S. military experts to visit to provide advice on bolstering the island’s defenses, the defense ministry said…, in the face of what Taipei views as a growing threat from its giant neighbor China… Taiwan’s Defense Ministry said it plans to use the ‘arms purchase contract model to invite a U.S. expert group to come to Taiwan’.”